Why Anna is right, Aruna and Andre are wrong…….

Though I am pressed for time and have stopped writing blogs quite for sometime, I thought I can atleast do this to support Anna. In recent days, it has become a rhetoric for experts and activists to question the method adopted by Anna. Prominent among such critics are Aruna Roy, a social activist and an ex- civil servant and Andre Beteille, a famous sociologist of India. The major concerns have been that such an act by Hazare and the civil society is an act of usurping the power that is the legitimate subject of the legislature. It is also said that Hazare activism will lead to anarchy and destabilising of the nation.

First of all, experts and academicians are using a structural-functional perspective which is criticized by many because of its tendency to always attribute ‘good’ functions to the structures that exist in society (Political institutions, economic institutions etc are called structure). Let me remind the critics of Anna that the structures including the democratic institutions in India are not ‘ideal’. Democracy itself is not representative because of first past the post system. Here we have a group of legislators who would pass a legislation to increase their salaries unopposed but would not pass a bill to make them accountable to Lokpal. A Lokpal which will not have jurisdiction over the legislature and judiciary is of no use and that exactly is the point made by Anna and the civil society. There is an unholy nexus between the legislative-executive-partly judiciary when it comes to making ill gotten wealth. It is a well known fact that you do not take permission from a goat before sacrificing it 🙂 This is exactly the situation where the legislators are required to pass a law that would bring their illegal activities under the scanner of the Lokpal.

The reasons provided like breach of privilege of members of parliament, creation of anarchy, etc is a ruling class ideology if I were to use the Marxian perspective. The dominant class here are the legislators (particularly the ruling government). Such ideologies are used to justify wrong practices to create a false consciousness among the ruled. Aruna Roy and Andre seem to be the victim of such false consciousness. If I were to use a functional perspective, I would say that Anna campaign has channeled the power of the youth to question the wrong practices. After independence, this is probably the first time that the youth of this country have come together in such large numbers. Thus, this is rightly called as the second war of Indian independence.

The fear that this will create a wrong precedent is unjustified because there are hardly few or I would go to the extent of saying that there are none like Anna Hazare who have that charismatic authority to unite the country against vices. We all know very well about the baba Ramdev fiasco.

Since when did we start calling the civil society demands as anarchy. Till today, I have been thinking that civil society is one of the most important pressure group. Moreover, this is no longer a part of the civil society as the whole nation is with Anna. Critics should stop underscoring the importance of structures and methods because no methods are followed when making ill gotten wealth. Moreover, this is not the right time for their criticism.

Lastly, I liked a placard at ground zero (Ramlila maidan) which said “Saari yuva yahan hain, Rahul Gandhi kahaan hain”. Not just Rahul, this is for all those ‘young’ MPs in our parliament who are in the parliament not because of their capability but because of dynasticism.

About guptasudhir

Let us revolutionize education in India !
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Why Anna is right, Aruna and Andre are wrong…….

  1. Pingback: JAN LOKPAL BILL : Prime Minister writes to Shri Anna Hazare « LAW RESOURCE INDIA

  2. Rajiv Gupta says:

    Deli-ma with the people in the chair is: ‘a situation where the legislators are required to pass a law that would bring their illegal activities under the scanner of the Lokpal.


  3. Shesharam says:

    Aruna Roy, Andre, Arundhati Roy or Nandan Nilekani may oppose the bill or the method adopted by Anna ji.

    Precisely, what have the above mentioned celebrities done about the rampant corruption in the “Palm & Co. Unlimited”? Now if these people cannot speak up and/or ideate some other alternative method to tackle corruption, they have no business to criticize Anna ji.

    Karan Thapar sits on a lofty pedestal and knows only how to question the proactive and responsible in Team Anna. What has the former done in this regard to question and criticize the very people who take such initiatives?

    As you rightly said, which corrupt government will dig its own grave by passing a stringent Lok pal bill? If the matter goes too far with an insensitive govt in place, the people’s anger will bring about a break down in the social and political machinery. Let the Congress & Co not forget how and why Lalu and Karunanidhi lost the elections


  4. Rajiv gupta says:

    Ideal would be to have a system where under a legislature/MP others in local governing bodies are subjected to period assessment on one contributions i.e. performance. Found failing to deliver OR perform; failing for successive 2 times per period say for a 6 mth period, one should be disqualified from his/her post held & election.
    Let he/she pave for for a new face. Longer durations aren’t of any help. Sloppiness sets-in!! Being seasoned people, the Politicians are supposed to perform from day-1!!
    Performance fear is bound to infuse accountability; pressure to work shall keep one fully booked throughout her/her assignment period!! Leaves no room for UN-scruples!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s